Citizen Petition from American Pastured Poultry Producers Association

David Shields of Pastured Life Farm, an independent family farm, supports the petition to establish clear FDA labeling standards for "pasture-raised" shell eggs. He argues that consistent standards aligned with USDA FSIS poultry meat requirements are necessary to prevent misleading marketing and protect producers who use authentic regenerative practices.

An individual commenter supports the American Pastured Poultry Producers Association's petition to establish a stricter definition for "pasture raised" eggs. They argue that current labeling is misleading and that consumers deserve transparency regarding the living conditions of the hens and the nutritional quality of the eggs.

An individual commenter argues that the term "pasture raised" for eggs lacks a proper definition and enforcement, leading to consumer deception. They urge the FDA to establish clear standards to ensure truth in advertising and protect farmers who use actual pasture.

A consumer is writing in support of the petition to establish a clear, enforceable definition for "Pasture Raised" egg labeling. They argue that current labeling lacks transparency and allows for "greenwashing," and that a science-based standard is necessary to protect consumers and ensure a level playing field for farmers who practice genuine pasture-based husbandry.