Alliance for Chemical Distribution
Trade associationSupport
Chemical sector applicability criteria
Town Hall Meetings To Provide Input on Cyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act (CIRCIA) Rulemaking
CISA-2022-0010-0480NPRM
Comments
23
Last activity Jul 14, 2026
Deadline
--
Net supportiSupport minus oppose · campaigns included
+39%
+39% excluding campaigns
Document
Details
The document's own metadata, straight from the source system.
- Title
- Town Hall Meetings To Provide Input on Cyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act (CIRCIA) Rulemaking
- Posted
- May 26, 2026
- FR Doc
- 2026-10417
- CFR
- 6 CFR Part 226
- Topics
Analysis
Overview
What the public is saying — stance, who's commenting, and the issues they raise.
Include campaigns
Stance breakdown
+39%
Net support
Support15Oppose6Other2
Aggregates include form-letter campaigns. Excluding them, net support is +39% across organic comments.
Who commented
Breakdown by commenter type.
Academic
1
Business
6
Individual
1
Government
1
Advocacy
1
Trade association
13
Comments over time
Weekly arrivals, stacked by stance.
Posted May 26, 2026
Jul 13
Support15Oppose6Other2
Support × commenter type
How each type splits across stance.
Support
Oppose
Other
Trade association
62%
38%
0%
Business
67%
17%
17%
Academic
100%
0%
0%
Individual
100%
0%
0%
Government
0%
0%
100%
Advocacy
100%
0%
0%
Issues raised
The docket's canonical issues. Select one to browse its comments.
Substantial cyber incident definition8
Reporting burden on small businesses2
Chemical sector applicability criteria1
Conflicting reporting requirements1
Impact on insurance coverage1
Isac integration and reporting1
Ot cyber incident identification1
Physical layer security and reporting1
Reporting process usability1
Sector-specific applicability criteria1
Position map
Who stands where on each issue?
Every non-silent position is backed by an excerpt from the comment.
Issues shown
Uncheck an issue to choose another.
| Organization | Reporting burden on small businesses | Chemical sector applicability criteria | Conflicting reporting requirements | Isac integration and reporting | Ot cyber incident identification |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alliance for Chemical Distribution Trade associationSupport The Alliance for Chemical Distribution (ACD) supports the CIRCIA rulemaking but urges CISA to narrow the scope of applic | · | · | · | · | |
American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association Trade associationOppose The American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association (ASLRRA) opposes the broad definition of "covered entities" in | · | · | · | · | |
Applied Control Solutions, LLC BusinessOther Joe Weiss, Managing Partner at Applied Control Solutions, LLC, provides feedback on the CIRCIA rulemaking regarding cont | · | · | · | · | |
Farm Credit Mid-America, ACA BusinessOppose Farm Credit Mid-America, ACA, submits supplemental comments on behalf of the Farm Credit System, expressing concerns reg | · | · | · | · | |
Health-ISAC, Inc. AdvocacySupport Errol Weiss, Chief Security Officer of Health-ISAC, supports the CIRCIA rulemaking but urges CISA to integrate Informati | · | · | · | · | |
Paragon D&E BusinessSupport Thomas Symons, IT Director at Paragon D&E, a small business in the Defense Industrial Base, supports the goal of the CIR | · | · | · | · | |
Pinnacle Systems Group LLC BusinessSupport Pinnacle Systems Group LLC, representing the AgGateway WG35 working group, supports the CIRCIA rulemaking but argues tha | · | · | · | · | · |
SIFMA Trade associationOppose SIFMA, representing the financial services industry, opposes the proposed CIRCIA rule because it imposes overly burdenso | · | · | · | · | · |
American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association
Trade associationOppose
Reporting burden on small businesses
Applied Control Solutions, LLC
BusinessOther
Ot cyber incident identification
Farm Credit Mid-America, ACA
BusinessOppose
Conflicting reporting requirements
Health-ISAC, Inc.
AdvocacySupport
Isac integration and reporting
Paragon D&E
BusinessSupport
Reporting burden on small businesses
Pinnacle Systems Group LLC
BusinessSupport
SIFMA
Trade associationOppose
Comments
Explorer
Every mirrored comment — filter by stance, campaign, or issue.
Filter:
- Jul 14, 2026Comment submitted by American Short Line and Regional Railroad AssociationOpposeTrade association📎 Attachment
The American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association (ASLRRA) opposes the broad definition of "covered entities" in the proposed CIRCIA rule, arguing it encompasses too many small railroads. They advocate for narrowing the scope to harmonize with the Transportation Security Administration’s (TSA) more limited applicability criteria and limiting third-party incident reporting to critical systems.
Read comment → - Jul 14, 2026Comment submitted by Paragon D&ESupportBusiness📎 Attachment
Thomas Symons, IT Director at Paragon D&E, a small business in the Defense Industrial Base, supports the goal of the CIRCIA rulemaking but argues that the current proposal creates duplicative reporting burdens for small firms already reporting to the DoD. He recommends operationalizing harmonization mechanisms to allow DIB contractors to satisfy CIRCIA requirements by reporting to the DoD, while also requesting a small-business exception or raised threshold for the residual scope gap.
Read comment →