Comment on VA-2026-VHA-0166-0001 (Anonymous)
Anonymous AnonymousOtherIndividual
Summary: A student expresses opposition to a proposed increase in immigration enforcement fees. However, their comment is off-topic as it addresses immigration fees rather than the proposed expansion of State Prescription Drug Monitoring Programs.
To Whom it may concern,
I'm writing this to express my concern regarding the proposal to raise the immigration enforcement fee from $5,130 to $18,000. While I understand that the government wants to cover its costs, I believe raising the fine by 250% if unrealistic and wont work.
Firstly, an $18,000 fine is too high for the vast majority of immigrants to ever pay. Instead of being helpful for the government, it's just trapping people in a massive amount of debt that they wont be able to escape. Additionally, there are a multitude of reasons someone may miss their court date, including changing addresses or mail being lost, though I understand looking into that on a case-by-case basis just raises the cost for the government even higher.
Secondly, according to the government's own breakdown in this document, the actual arrests only cost $1,777. The rest of the $18,000 comes from the cost of keeping detainees in a facility. It doesn't make sense to charge a person thousands of dollars for the cost of their own, involuntary detention.
What I suggest: Instead of the $18,000 fee, the government should limit the fine to $2,422 to cover the actual costs of identifying & arresting individuals. This way, the government can still cover a portion of its costs while not putting people in crippling debt.
Thank you,
A concerned student