Comment Submitted by Mateo Burgos
Mateo BurgosSupportIndividual
Summary: Mateo Burgos, a student, supports the Coast Guard's proposal to establish Shipping Safety Fairways but recommends specific improvements. He argues for more detailed regional tradeoff analyses, clearer cumulative and climate impact assessments, explicit commitments to adaptive management monitoring, and ongoing stakeholder coordination.
To Whom It May Concern,
I am Mateo Burgos, and I am providing this public comment as a student about the Coast Guard’s Draft Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement/Overseas EIS concerning the establishment of Shipping Safety Fairways and related vessel routing measures along the Atlantic Coast (Docket USCG-2023-0928).
I support the goal of improving navigational safety and reducing conflicts among ocean users. However, I recommend the final PEIS/OEIS be strengthened in these specific ways:
Clearer tradeoff analysis by region: Please provide a more detailed comparison of how alternatives affect risk and impacts across sub-regions (e.g., Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, Southeast), including navigation safety, fisheries, marine mammals, seabirds, and offshore wind development.
Cumulative and climate-related impacts: Given the programmatic nature, the analysis should provide a clearer examination of cumulative impacts and how evolving conditions (such as increased storm intensity and alterations in ocean use patterns) may influence routing effectiveness over time.Observation and adaptive management: Please include more explicit commitments for monitoring
(vessel traffic patterns, near-miss/collision indicators, wildlife interactions) and specify “triggers” for adjusting routing measures if impacts or conflicts increase.
Stakeholder coordination: Maintain ongoing consultations with Tribes, coastal communities, fisheries, conservation groups, and offshore wind stakeholders to reduce unintended impacts and enhance compliance.
I appreciate the chance to provide feedback. I advocate for advancing the project with these enhancements, which would boost transparency and reinforce long-term effectiveness.
Sincerely,
Mateo Burgos